Sorry, but I'm about die of laughing at people thinking HOTD is a good choice. Although I'm as enthusiastic at SnK S2 as you guys, since it's pretty average when it comes to everything, except it's animation, which I'll give it credit for.
Personally, I'm waiting for the confirmation of a second season of
Mondaiji-tachi ga Isekai kara Kuru Sou Desu yo? and the adaptation of the Time Traveler arc from
The World God Only Knows, but considering how they ended the Goddess Arc, it doesn't look like they'll be adapting this one, which makes me very sad since The World God Only Knows is, imo, one of the better anime to come out in recent years.
I also saw that someone mentioned that they'd like to see a second season of Angel Beats! Now, I don't think a second season would do it justice. I'd rather have an entire remake with 24 episodes instead of the 13 we got. Angel Beats!' downfall was it's low amount of episodes. If it had 24 episodes, Angel Beats! might've been close to the #1 spot on MAL (not saying #82 is a bad rank, but y'know...).
As I'm looking through my list of completed anime (300+, so it took a while), I see one anime movie that I've been waiting ages for. The dreaded Kizumonogatari, which is the prequel to the entire Monogatari Series (my favorite anime franchise). I swear to god SHAFT is feeding off our tears. It's been 2 years since it was announced, damnit.
Other anime I found on my list that I'd like to see an extra season for:
- Hyouka
- Nisekoi
- Noragami
- Outbreak Company
- Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo (YES PLEASE)