I'm trying to remain unbiased here, but you have to admit this is a confusing and difficult situation for Morgan, so you need to cut him some slack there.

However, Morgan, what I feel like you should've done is to just mention that it will be brought up in the meeting and stopped there. In the meeting, you should add his proof but mention the possibility of lying, because completely denying his proof is understandably frustrating.

Gmod, you really should've stopped constantly contacting him and seeming "desperate", as that just makes you more suspicious. It also unnecessarily escalates the situation. If you feel this report was 100% needed, you should've made it privately to a CM+ because this starts unnecessary drama.

I'm trying to remain unbiased here, but you have to admit this is a confusing and difficult situation for Morgan, so you need to cut him some slack there. However, Morgan, what I feel like you should've done is to just mention that it will be brought up in the meeting and stopped there. In the meeting, you should add his proof but mention the possibility of lying, because completely denying his proof is understandably frustrating. Gmod, you really should've stopped constantly contacting him and seeming "desperate", as that just makes you more suspicious. It also unnecessarily escalates the situation. If you feel this report was 100% needed, you should've made it privately to a CM+ because this starts unnecessary drama.