Although you did break a rule you're fully correct that Silent should not have straight up punished you. Users are always supposed to be taken into a sit if they're on the server - if what you say is true then Silent carried out his duties wrongly.

Although the warning is technically valid, I would still accept this as the staff member screwed up. If your story checks out, obviously - if Silent doesn't confirm your story I don't think you'll get far, as you have no proof.

Although you did break a rule you're fully correct that Silent should not have straight up punished you. Users are always supposed to be taken into a sit if they're on the server - if what you say is true then Silent carried out his duties wrongly. Although the warning is technically valid, I would still accept this as the staff member screwed up. If your story checks out, obviously - if Silent doesn't confirm your story I don't think you'll get far, as you have no proof.