I always urge staff members to open a chat when handling sticky situations. Especially situations where someone claims to have KOSed someone else always need to be talked out, as 10-150 character box isn't enough to describe the situation.
In other words, if it were me handling this request I'd accept it - as I'm not on Teamspeak right now or near my computer, I'll let Xnator decide what the proper course of action is after having discussed it with Cranky and Joligeman himself.
BBCode