If this is all true then sure he should get demoted. Since there is no evidence i know nothing will happen. And from what i have seen Tyler is probably one of the most honest and respectful lead team member+ that there is in the community currently i see him helping out all over the place with stuff he shouldn't even have to. I dont know if its just me or he generally is like that to everyone, i have only seen good stuff from Tyler as a CM... Not as good as me though