You mean he broke raid timer ?

Anyway on ( explain how you would handle...) you said " i will ask in staff chat what i need to do with the player " you need to know what you should do, because sometimes you would be the only staff online in the server.

And you said that you will verbal warn player "a" who made the f1 because of Lying, maybe he didnt know that the other player didnt rdm.

Your activity is not really good, last time i saw you on server 1 you wasnt really friendly and you was disrespectful,

Sorry my verdict is

For the following reasons:

1. Needs to improve activity
2. Needs to control anger