Hello jedijack,
Your mod app says under the"how would you handle this situation" for the rdm one, it says "I would punish the player not following the logs" please explain how the logs tell the story just the logs saying player y killed player x or vice versa. This does not tell the story so you wouldn't punish the person who's story does not follow the logs.....I don't understand this so please explain it more and give better examples, and fix your mod app up a little and put more effort into it but for now -Supporttry to fix this and I may change my verdict.
Thanks