Hello Stewie,
Due to the corruption on here I was silenced from asking you what I need in order to give appropriate feedback.
That said, I will go with a neutral support here. Best of luck!

Due to the nature of your question I can only answer with, I would take both parties involved too a roof to get both sides of the story. From there I would determine if "rdm" took place or any "rule breaks" if so I would check the rap sheet and if it was clean I would give a verbal warning, if not clean (it isn't) I would give a warning or a 5 minute jail.