Spoons provided his evidence which shows him not participating, then getting arrested by you.
You claimed that you had external information telling you that spoons was infact still participating, yet had no evidence to back this up.

Spoons provided evidence that was also backed by the logs, you did not, ergo, you got warned

Spoons provided his evidence which shows him not participating, then getting arrested by you. You claimed that you had external information telling you that spoons was infact still participating, yet had no evidence to back this up. Spoons provided evidence that was also backed by the logs, you did not, ergo, you got warned