Hey Quimoth,
After talking to all staff members involved, reading through the posts (Ignoring all the useless stuff/hate messages.) I have decided to deny this report.

I have one main reason for this. Broken himself really did not do anything wrong other than keep the report. Broken himself did not punish you.

Even if this was on the staff member that punished you, PZgrens, I would still have denied this report.
The punishment was valid as you RDMed Broken. You have changed your story three times and while I understand what you are trying to say and I understand why you killed him but it does not make your reasons valid. After talking with both staff members it's clear to me you were not next to PZgrens the entire round to know everything he had done up to that point and it shows in your report since nowhere in it did you mention PZgrens shot first.

Your argument that "I heard 3 guns so I know there had to be 2 traitors" is invalid. If you did not witness Broken shoot you would have had no idea if the shots were right outside the cave or in the cave. This is effectively KOSing on weapon/weapon sounds.

You also mention multiple times "I can kill him for not taking action" in regards to him watching someone kill the detective. This is just incorrect. You can't force a player to take any action they don't want to. If the guy lets another guy get away with killing a detective so be it. You can follow them and keep high suspicion on them but it is far from 100% proof that they are the traitor if you asked me.

Even further than that, him shooting in your general direction is not T-baiting since he was clearly shooting at PZgrens. You even used it in one of your replies as the reason you killed him. "I kill C for it because it was WAY to obvious he was actually aiming for me"

Also what do you mean IF Broken turned out to be innocent he would have been joining a gunfight? PZgrens did not attempt to fight anyone other than Broken via the logs you have sent. Someone rule-breaking by joining a gunfight does not give you permission to break a rule and RDM that player either.

Lastly your biggest issues in general is that you are making a lot of claims of what people saw and that a player did this and another player did that but you have no video proof whatsoever of any of this. The majority of your whole post is just you making a bunch of claims and you can't confirm any of them with evidence. The only evidence you provided was that screenshot of the logs. The logs do not prove that Broken shot right next to you, nor do they prove PZgrens had not fired a single shot that round.

I don't want you to misunderstand this either. I understand your reasoning and because of the giant mess this situation is, I will take off your joining a gunfight warning. It does not mean you did not break the rule, I just don't believe it was not malicious enough to warrant a warning.

Your attitude on the server and throughout this post has been terrible. You are insulting people for disagreeing with you and insulting staff members for defending other staff members. Just because people defending the staff member for enforcing a rule does not mean they in any way support that rule. They just understand why the punishment was given and don't think the staff member should be punished for doing it.



No action will be taken against either of the staff members.

Thank you for the report, your warn will be removed shortly.