Forum

Login to ZARP

[TTT] Agaricus Bisporus' Punishment Appeal

View BBCode Back »

Eddie. wrote:

Henny wrote:

Just want to point this out to both Lotto and David before I speak to David about this

2.6 Valid KOS Reasons
- Pushing someone with a crowbar near an edge or hazard.

Could that possibly be understood as you can kill someone for pushing yourself near an edge/hazard, but not for pushing someone else? (The same way you could kill someone for shooting at yourself, but not for shooting at another player unless you knew that player had not committed any traitorous acts). I do see their viewpoint in that if you see a player pushing someone near an edge/hazard, you don’t know if the player they are pushing is a traitor, and therefore this could still come under joining fights just as much as killing someone who is shooting at another player.

Not sure my opinion on this appeal, but maybe that valid KOS reason isn’t the best, as it doesn’t exactly fit with the PvP rule.

Their logic on this is quite odd. They are basically saying traitors can go around pushing AFKs off edges and as long as it doesn't kill them, you can't kill them as you have no information if they are a T or not.
Also the rule doesn't state that you are the one being pushed off the edge, rather it just states pushing someone off an edge = KOS. I understand where the confusion could come from and I will try to change it Sunday.

BBCode

[quote="Eddie." post=1163706][quote="Henny" post=1163696]Just want to point this out to both Lotto and David before I speak to David about this
[code]2.6 Valid KOS Reasons
- Pushing someone with a crowbar near an edge or hazard.[/code][/quote] Could that possibly be understood as you can kill someone for pushing yourself near an edge/hazard, but not for pushing someone else? (The same way you could kill someone for shooting at yourself, but not for shooting at another player unless you knew that player had not committed any traitorous acts). I do see their viewpoint in that if you see a player pushing someone near an edge/hazard, you don’t know if the player they are pushing is a traitor, and therefore this could still come under joining fights just as much as killing someone who is shooting at another player.

Not sure my opinion on this appeal, but maybe that valid KOS reason isn’t the best, as it doesn’t exactly fit with the PvP rule.[/quote]
Their logic on this is quite odd. They are basically saying traitors can go around pushing AFKs off edges and as long as it doesn't kill them, you can't kill them as you have no information if they are a T or not.
Also the rule doesn't state that you are the one being pushed off the edge, rather it just states pushing someone off an edge = KOS. I understand where the confusion could come from and I will try to change it Sunday.

Forum

[TTT] Agaricus Bisporus' Punishment Appeal

Time to create page: 0.066 seconds