This is exactly like perp and that is probably why it will never happen you are creating something to live in the glory of something else. Most of the time that doesn't work and you pulling the excuse of "why don't you do it" its because it would take ages getting back to the "good old days".
Really I wouldn't mind disabling some items on certain days and seeing how that goes. Heck I wouldn't even mind disabling it on maybe server 2 but you would have to say what you would like otherwise making a whole new server is an annoying and time-consuming and generally won't do what you think it will for the community.
BBCode