Even though I've never seen you nor interacted with you I'll give you some feedback to work on.
Firstly, when applying for any server in the ZARP community, it is strongly recommended that you have 2 weeks of consistent activity, which you don't, unfortunately. Moving on, you application seems perfectly fine, though i just wanted to make you aware that:
I would bring them but if player Y admits right there I would give him a verbal if it his first warning in a while but, if player Y had more than 10 recents in the past days I would probably do a more severe punishment.
This many recent punishments warrants a 2 week ban. So instead of filling a User's Rapsheet with more warns/mutes, you would call an Administrator to determine an appropriate ban.