Forum

Login to ZARP

View BBCode Back »

dingofetch wrote:

Orion wrote:

Miia wrote:

Orion wrote:

Harry declared an invalid KOS on Prestige, as I've already pointed out and as I pointed out before you shut down the discussion. EDIT: The body was also identified before I shot Harry.

But in that situation a traitor could see that Harry called a false KOS, kill Harry and then be unable to be killed for it. Despite committing a traitorous act he becomes untouchable and protected by the rules.

Yes, that's a risk when innocents RDM other innocents. Harry committed a treasonous offense, so I killed him, as is my right within the confines of the rules. You're saying that all that matters is the outcome, and the context is irrelevant. You're saying that you need to know in advance whether or not someone is an innocent or a traitor, before you can kill them for committing actions that validate KOS's in the first place.

False KOS's are KOSable.
Killing an innocent is KOSable.
Apply that logic to ANY QUESTION YOU HAVE and it will be solved all on it's own.

Then what is the point of having a list of things that make for valid KOS's if you're just going to ignore all that and focus on whether the person who committed those actions is an innocent or a traitor after they've been killed?

BBCode

[quote="dingofetch" post=1029257][quote="Orion" post=1029256][quote="Miia" post=1029251][quote="Orion" post=1029243]Harry declared an invalid KOS on Prestige, as I've already pointed out and as I pointed out before you shut down the discussion. EDIT: The body was also identified before I shot Harry.[/quote]
But in that situation a traitor could see that Harry called a false KOS, kill Harry and then be unable to be killed for it. Despite committing a traitorous act he becomes untouchable and protected by the rules.[/quote]

Yes, that's a risk when innocents RDM other innocents. Harry committed a treasonous offense, so I killed him, as is my right within the confines of the rules. You're saying that all that matters is the outcome, and the context is irrelevant. You're saying that you need to know in advance whether or not someone is an innocent or a traitor, before you can kill them for committing actions that validate KOS's in the first place.[/quote]

False KOS's are KOSable.
Killing an innocent is KOSable.
Apply that logic to ANY QUESTION YOU HAVE and it will be solved all on it's own.[/quote]
Then what is the point of having a list of things that make for valid KOS's if you're just going to ignore all that and focus on whether the person who committed those actions is an innocent or a traitor after they've been killed?

Forum

RDM or not?

View BBCode Back »

BBCode

Quick Menu

Menu

157 PLAYERS ONLINE

ZARP Discord & Steam Group