Depends on a lot. If you saw him kill bosscomic as well then yeah you can 100% kill him. As for him killing the other guy, if you had been following hey im adam from the very start of the round so can confirm that he had committed no traitorous acts then i would also say you could kill eddie, but this cannot be confirmed by only the logs. It looks like what happened is you shot him then stop to let him identify the body, after he identified it as innocent you then killed him. Which would be joining a fight as without further proof he could have had DNA on hey im adam.