I did mute the both of you for continuing the argument after being told not to.

This is petty, imo. You were both handled accordingly. And even though you claimed to have been satirical in your remarks and that they were "harmless" it instigated the argument.

EDIT: the reason you dont see the mute is because im a proper staff member that talks to people before they're punished. its a little farther down, bud.