Zikinan, the person has the option to forgive you right after you reply to the report. If the Staff Member is kind enough, he might even give you another chance in the Chat. Since the other guy didn't forgive you in both Report and Chat, Jax has every right to punish you. As for the proof of your "broken mouse" that is not sufficient. I can unplug my mouse, move it around and have the same result.

Zikinan, the person has the option to forgive you right after you reply to the report. If the Staff Member is kind enough, he might even give you another chance in the Chat. Since the other guy didn't forgive you in both Report and Chat, Jax has every right to punish you. As for the proof of your "broken mouse" that is not sufficient. I can unplug my mouse, move it around and have the same result.