Anyways, after having taken a proper look at the video I do believe you're partly right: Xnator screwed up on several fronts.

1. TheRealSatan was not muted (as far as I'm aware)
2. He did not TP to you to explain to you why you were getting muted. When we give punishments to users, we're supposed to get them into a sit - not just straight up mute and let it slide.
3. Instead of handling the situation appropriately, he decided to call you out in OOC chat. This would only cause more issues rather than solve them.
4. Although you were told by MsMs to not spam F1s, you were never properly approached about the matter. Once again you were straight up punished without being brought into a sit.

However, the punishments given are valid, although Xnator did not handle the situation as well as he should have done.