I believe you are both right in different arguments that you make.
-Before we get started, please note that even though I am currently IN the Billionaire's gang I will be as unbiased as possible in my argument. I will give arguments for both sides of this topic.
I am going to make arguments from experience, not speculation.
I am going to start this with an argument for Billionaire and then for Ace, but I may mix in arguments for both sides in each section.
Okay well in sequence...
a. I come into the server as a new player, I get invited to a gang & get $100K cash from my gang members
b. I now enjoy knowing i'm in a team, I have team members already in a server I just joined.
c. I have money to use in the server, if I get frustrated about losing a printer that cost me my whole $10,000 RP cash i'm way less likely to flip out right?
d. So I get raided, lose my printer, but guess what? Instead of flipping out, since I got so much RP cash from my new gang teammates I carry on & base with them.
e. I make friends in the server & start to progress. Making friends makes me more inclined to RETURN or CONTINUE PLAYING.
f. So here I am, a new player, I have a few friends in a server I just joined. Should I rulebreak? Well if i'm RB Type #2 then I definitely would have to think it over... Can I calm myself down? Do I have something to lose other than my entry to this server? *YES FRIENDS & NOW TIME INVESTED*
g. I decide whether I want to rulebreak or if I can control myself I don't.
I am relatively new to this server. I started playing consistently back in July and I have now and now understand how this server works.
- I agree with the fact that new players should be able to have people to work with.
Let me tell you from experience. Playing ZARP SSRP without a gang or friends to play with is NOT the most fun thing in the world.
When you join a gang or have some feeling of having people to rely on in SSRP, you
WILL have a better time. I know this from experience.
On my first day of ZARP, I was raging so hard that I actually got lightheaded and had to walk away for hours before I calmed down. (I am a lot calmer now. I had a stressful Summer.) If I had some people to help me, I would have not raged as hard and broken some rules on my first day. (Mostly NLR, I got warned.)
My counterargument to this is that the gang members may act in a way that promotes rulebreaking. In order to do this correctly, the gang needs to be watched over with a careful eye from people who are more experienced. Also, some people cannot calm themselves in a stressful situation. Point "f" is partially true but also has some flaws.
- If people feel 'loved' they won't necessarily stop rulebreaking every once in a while.
This is true, although the goal is not to COMPLETELY eradicate rulebreaking--a task that is impossible--but you are correct.
NOTHING can completely eliminate rulebreaking.
- Mentioning Trump&Brexit is a bit far fetched, which have more to do with a rise in nationalism caused by multiple factors in the western world like immigration and economic crisis's than with "not having enough love"
You are correct in that statement. Those events happened for completely different reasons and are pretty much irrelevant in this post.
- You talk about how people "harass" new players, which is something only a minority of dickheads do. When a new player asks for help in ooc, their questions immediately get answered and there's always someone willing to help them out.
This may sound a little biased, I am sorry in advance.
In my experience, there are a lot more of the quote-on-quote,"dickheads" than you would think. Sure, questions may be answered in chat, but other than that, experienced players tend not to tolerate and assist newer players.
BUT there are some exceptions; in fact,
MANY exceptions. There are people on this server who really care about new players. I would say it is about 75% of the people who play are willing to help newer players (not an actual statistic, I cannot collect that data.)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f6166/f61666cf9401d79f8d91df48c76d8ba825f35230" alt=":P :P"
But that other 25% can cause major issues with new players.
- Don't ever try to apply real world knowledge into Zarp, this community is literally unique in a sense that you can barely declare anything in it. Try explaining why rare item prices go up in an update where they are temporarily available again. Simple rules like demand&supply don't apply here.
Except for the Supply&Demand portion of this argument, I do agree the general idea you are implying in this argument is in fact valid. This server certainly does not work like the real world, but like its own separate thing. (Supply and Demand does exist it is just weird and not as clear-cut as most people expect it to be as the markets are a little less controlled on ZARP.
Without wanting to point my fingers
PenE - first day of billionaires vowed to raid us everyday
Sam The Sausage - RDM All Day our 2nd day, & Raids
Mytic - Mass RDM
Clark - Mass RDM / Raid *We had no raidables once again just for fun*
Basically Everyone in Born in Blood
Basically Everyone in Frag Angels
Bobby Bobby *However he apologized & helped them after*
+ More I don't even feel like naming.
Alright, this is something you should
NEVER do in a post. It drives hate towards these people when most of the time, they don't deserve the amount of hate they get. (You would be surprised.) It is not just to name names on a post like this and try to direct hate towards these people. Its not a nice thing to do. Also, you did exactly what you said you weren't going to do: point fingers.
In conclusion you are both correct about certain things in your arguments, but they both have flaws. You both have valid points and I made this post to kind of support discussion before anyone takes a side.
-Thank you for taking time out of your day to hear my spiel about this topic. Thanks and see you in-game!
If I sounded biased, honestly just tell me how I was and I will try to fix it. I want my argument to be as neutral as possible.
(Just don't say it in a nasty way.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93225/93225bc10579b9f629bf66bca51f6d0b2ceca175" alt=":) :)"
)